The Knockturnal
  • Home
  • Entertainment
  • Music
  • Lifestyle
  • News
  • Videos
  • Covers
  • Merch
ArtLifestyleThe Latest

“Programmed: Rules, Codes, and Choreographies in Art, 1965-2018” Opens at the Whitney

by Reyna Wang October 2, 2018
by Reyna Wang October 2, 2018 0 comments
3.5K

We’ve all heard that successful artists “break the rules” of art. Ironically, some artists have “broken the rules” of the art world by embracing rules and programs traditionally associated with the tech world, responding to its increasing importance in our lives.

These are the artists shown in the Whitney’s newest exhibition, Programmed: Rules, Codes, and Choreographies in Art, 1965-2018, sponsored by Audi. The exhibition is unique in that the Whitney owns all featured pieces, which occur in a wide range of media. Programmed examines the connections among works of art that are “programmed” using instructions, tracing how instructions in art have evolved over fifty years in response to the growing reliance on automated systems. The exhibition is organized by two main strands of analysis, within which works are grouped into more specific thematic sections. The first strand, titled “Rule, Instruction, Algorithm,” explores programs that are emphasized for their own conceptual or aesthetic value as mechanisms of visual creation. The second, “Signal, Sequence, Resolution,” explores programs used to manipulate televisions and other displays of digital images, generating novel experiences and environments that reflect the Information Age.

The exhibition begins with a section titled “Collapsing Introduction and Form,” which features some of the oldest works in Programmed. Among these are pieces by Josef Albers and Sol LeWitt, pioneers of conceptual art that emphasizes the underlying systems driving a work’s material form. Their works provide historical context for how the programmatic approach to conceptual art has evolved with the development of technology. Albers is best known for creating paintings as a system of analyzing color theory. His geometric abstractions in various color combinations demonstrate that our perceptions of individual colors are relative to the colors around them. LeWitt is best known for creating sets of instructions for wall drawings that could be executed by anyone. In Programmed, their works are juxtaposed with more contemporary pieces that they influenced, which adapt the roles of rules and instructions to computers.

John F. Simon Jr., Color Panel v1.0, 1999, photo by San Francisco Museum of Modern Art

Two of Albers’ paintings, including one from his iconic Homage to the Square series, are hung next to John F. Simon Jr.’s software art piece, Color Panel v1.0. This piece consists of a small laptop that has been hung vertically on a wall with its keyboard removed, displaying a composition of shifting rectangles that draws from motifs of geometric abstraction. The intricacy and tiny scale of this work draw the viewer closer, but it’s practically impossible to deduce without reading the wall label that the display is actually composed of multiple systems programmed to calculate the mixing of colors based on randomly selected combinations, a focus inspired by Albers’ work. For instance, one system involves tiny bouncing squares in randomly generated colors, which eventually compress into a bar that is the averaged color of the squares. One system of moving squares in the display actually functions as a clock whose complete run would span over hundreds of years, symbolizing the piece’s eternal timeline since color selection is left up to chance.

Casey Reas, {Software} Structure #003 B, 2004 and 2016, photo by Whitney Museum of American Art

One of the four walls of LeWitt’s Wall Drawing #289 is installed adjacent to Casey Reas’ {Software} Structure #003, consisting of two black and white projections showing the movement of one hundred circles throughout a surface. The first system (A) connects the intersections of circles as they overlap, creating a mesmerizing display of short, shifting black lines, while the second (B) records these changes over time in a process similar to a long exposure photograph, producing a chaotic array of growing and fading disc-like forms. Reas was inspired by LeWitt’s concept of creating only the instructions for a work of art, but instead of producing written guidelines and diagrams so that the execution can be handed over to other people, he produces code so that the execution is handed to a computer. The instructions underlying both works allow for variation each time they are executed: LeWitt’s guidelines for wall drawings include some leeway for adaptation to different architectural contexts, whereas Reas’ code generates randomized movement that never repeats itself.

Fascination with code’s ability to generate randomness and infinite variation is also present in the works of Cheney Thomson, Alex Dodge, and Ian Cheng, featured in the section called “Generative Measures.” To produce “generative art,” artists hand over artistic control to programs that act autonomously to produce the material works, which have their own aesthetic merit despite the conceptual art’s emphasis on the artist’s idea. And while aesthetic creativity is traditionally associated with imagination, considered unique to the human mind, artists who give agency to programmed chance are able to create the unimaginable. In this way, their works raise questions about the essences of creativity and authorship, and they reflect the changing role of human labor and intelligence in our increasingly automated societies.

The last section in “Rule, Instruction, and Algorithm,” titled “Collapsing Instruction and Form,” features artists who use the language of artistic instruction as its material form, deconstructing the duality that other conceptual artists had reinforced. The piece I found most interesting in this section was W. Bradford Paley’s Code Profiles, a video work that displays the progression of a programmed drawing superimposed over the very code that is generating it, as well as a white line that traces the mouse of the programmer as they activate different parts of the code. By highlighting lines of code to indicate when they are being executed and running the program at a pace readable by humans, Paley makes the instructions of his work accessible yet still largely incomprehensible to the majority of viewers, emphasizing the vastly different ways that people and computers process instructions and the role that the programmer plays in bridging that gap.

The second strand of artistic exploration is introduced by a section called “Image Resequenced,” which examines the use of rules and code to rearrange images. At its forefront is Nam June Paik’s Fin de Siècle II, one of the most visually compelling and memorable works in Programmed. The massive work is comprised of 270 stacked televisions of various sizes that display montages of edited clips from unrelated television programs and art videos, including, most notably, close-up footage of David Bowie’s face. By creating a program that shows different moving images on different televisions, that rotates certain images or stretches them across a grid of multiple screens, and that accompanies the display with upbeat electronic music, Paik replicates and augments the feelings of overstimulation, confusion, and hypnosis that often result from excessive exposure to electronic media. Though the work was created and last exhibited almost 30 years ago, its aesthetic is surprisingly trendy, and its commentary on the overwhelming nature of digital media is more relevant than ever in the age of smartphones and social media.

Jim Campbell, Tilted Plane, 2011, photo by Whitney Museum of American Art

The next section, “Liberating the Signal,” features artists who use electronic and digital signals outside of the contexts of their original functions. One of these artists is Jim Campbell, whose installation Tilted Plane is another standout piece. The installation builds upon Campbell’s approach in his “low-resolution” works, also on display, which explore the challenge of using individual units of lights to display a decipherable moving image. Tilted Plane further questions what constitutes a screen by applying this approach to image construction in an immersive, three-dimensional format. Hundreds of custom-made LED bulbs hang from the ceiling and function collectively as the array of pixels constituting a huge, tilted, extremely low-resolution screen. The bulbs flicker as images are transmitted through the matrix of signals governing the bulbs, but their flickering appears to be random as the images are completely indecipherable. As you walk under the bulbs and eventually between them as they hang closer and closer to the ground, your perception of the screen becomes increasingly abstracted, as you have now essentially walked through the screen and are peering through the other side.

Mendi + Keith Obadike, The Interaction of Coloreds, 2002 and 2018, screenshot

“Realities and Codes” showcases works that use programs to critique social codes and rules. Using an interactive, satirical website to draw attention to racism in the realm of online commerce, Mendi + Keith Obadike’s The Interaction of Coloreds is innovative and socially. The website’s Color Check System is a skin-color verification system that museum visitors can use to translate photos of their skin tone into hexadecimal numbers, used to represent color in HTML. Using the System to codify one’s precise skin tone is an undeniably amusing activity, but it also reflects serious real-world anxieties concerning privacy and discrimination on the internet, such fear of the growing effectiveness of electronic devices as tools for collecting personal information, or concern about the disproportionate targeting of people of color by government or corporate internet surveillance.

The exhibition concludes with an augmented reality project by Tamiko Thiel called Unexpected Growth. Imagining that the Whitney was underwater due to climate change, Thiel programmed a virtual growth on the Whitney’s sixth-floor terrace, consisting of coral littered with a variety of plastic objects that had ended up in the ocean of his imagination. Though Thiel certainly projects a foreboding vision of the future, the growth’s bright colors and whimsical forms of litter, including flip-flops and rubber ducks, create an element of playfulness. The most aspect of Unexpected Growth is that it is programmed to mimic nature in its response to overuse of resources: visitors experiencing the environment stimulate the corals’ growth, but once the number of visitors passes a certain threshold, the corals begin bleaching and die off. This interactive component shows that our technologies can be effectively programmed to resemble natural processes and that perhaps there is hope for harmony between nature and our increasingly mechanized world.

Programmed demonstrates excellent thematic organization, impressive restoration efforts, and thoughtful curation that challenges us to question the role of technological programs and to examine our changing relationships with digital media and automated systems.

The exhibition runs until April of 2019, and I would highly recommend making some time before then to go experience its diverse, interactive, and immersive works.

abstract artAudiconceptual artcontemporary artthe whitneyThe Whitney Museum
0 comments 0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
Reyna Wang

previous post
Carey Mulligan, Paul Dano & Zoe Kazan Talk ‘Wildlife’ at NYFF Premiere
next post
In Conversation: The Britanys’ Steele Kratt

Related Posts

Baekhyun ‘Climbs Up Our Hearts’ with Dreamy ‘Reverie’...

July 8, 2025

A Garden in the Sky: Fourth of July...

July 8, 2025

Splendid Summer with Peroni and Giada De Laurentiis

July 8, 2025

Macy’s Fourth of July Fireworks Sparkle Bright at...

July 5, 2025

Karen Bernod’s Return to the Spotlight: 25 Years...

July 4, 2025

Review: ‘Heads of State’ Brings Comedy to The...

July 3, 2025

Ghosts of Hell Creek: A Prehistoric Dance of...

July 3, 2025

Savoring Summer with Mi Campo: 3 Cocktails That...

July 3, 2025

From Tiki to Limoncello: NYC’s Coolest Summer Bars...

July 2, 2025

Sky Sparks & Dance Floor Heat: 4th of...

July 2, 2025

Digital Cover No. 19

The Knockturnal Merch

Follow Us On The Gram

theknockturnal

Lifestyle. Music. Entertainment.
Info@theknockturnal.com
New Cover Out Now ⬇️

Sweet as “Candy,” and as high as an “Elevato Sweet as “Candy,” and as high as an “Elevator…” 🍬

On July 6th, at the iconic Kia Forum in Los Angeles, the beloved Korean idol @baekhyunee_exo took the stage for the last U.S. stop of his first ever solo tour under his own label, @inb100_official. ✨

🔗 https://theknockturnal.com/baekhyun/ 

#Baekhyun #INB100 #Kpop #KpopConcert #ReviereTour #Reviere #EXO
✨ Red, white, and boom! ✨ Macy’s iconic @mac ✨ Red, white, and boom! ✨
Macy’s iconic @macys Fourth of July Fireworks lit up the night sky over the Brooklyn Bridge in a dazzling display of light, sound, and celebration. 

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/macys-fourth-of-july-fireworks-sparkle-bright-at-brooklyn-bridge/

-
#MacysFireworks #BrooklynBridge #FourthOfJuly #NYCSummer
@lorde “Virgin” is more than an album — it’s an aural snapshot of an artist on the brink of redefining pop music. Step inside Lorde’s world, with us. 🎧🩻

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/virgin-an-x-ray-of-lordes-sonic-arrival/

✍️: Jesse Kosierowski

-
#Lorde #Virgin #MusicReview #PopCulture
Meet @dominiquethorne , the rising star behind “ Meet @dominiquethorne , the rising star behind “Ironheart”, @marvelstudios newest @disneyplus show. From Wakanda to a tech-powered hero, she shares the journey, challenges, and excitement of suiting up as Riri Williams. Get ready for a fresh take on heroism! 🔥💥

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/dominique-thorne-talks-new-marvel-tv-show-ironheart-on-disney/

✍️: OJ Williams

-
 #Ironheart #MarvelTV #DisneyPlus #DominiqueThorne
Taron Egerton’s range is unreal, and in his late Taron Egerton’s range is unreal, and in his latest project, he’s turning up the heat, literally! We chatted with him for Smoke at @tribeca! 💨🔥
Real fire, real life, Smoke on @appletv has it all Real fire, real life, Smoke on @appletv has it all! We chatted with director Dennis Lehane at @tribeca! 🔥💨
Anna Chlumsky talks working with Dennis Lehane (an Anna Chlumsky talks working with Dennis Lehane (and real fire!) at the world premiere of Smoke on @appletv @tribeca!
The Future of Black Music is NOW! 🎶🎵🎤 We The Future of Black Music is NOW! 🎶🎵🎤

We got the chance to profile 5 amazing new artist and, just know, BLACK music is in great hands!

Check out our profiles on @thefcknartist @niko.noir @babyfaceray @veezeworst @ynjay_ 

Detroit, don’t miss out! Come experience the Future of Black Music live! 🎧🎸🥁🎹🎺🎻

With live performances of today’s best emerging artists. 

RSVP now in the bio to come visit the culture. ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Detroit! Are you ready to experience the Future of Detroit! Are you ready to experience the Future of Black Music! 🎶🎵🎤

Presented by Smirnoff Lemonades & BCode, curated by The Basement Series. Come see the movement move forward! 

RSVP now in the bio to come experience the culture. ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨
Cutting-edge scares, killer dance moves, and AI ch Cutting-edge scares, killer dance moves, and AI chaos 💃🤖
@m3gan 2.0 is the wild ride your summer needed. Read our full take! 

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/m3gan-2-0-is-ridiculous-over-the-top-fun-but-also-poses-important-questions-about-ai/

✍️: Ishan Wankavala

-
#M3GAN2 #AIHorror #SciFiThriller #HorrorComedy #SummerMovies #TechTerror #AIQuestions #MovieReview #CampyHorror
Mini fashion moments, major throwback energy 👛 Mini fashion moments, major throwback energy 👛
@shopcider x @pollypocket took over @alfred with tiny accessories, buttery croissants, and all the Y2K feels 💅☕

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/tiny-fashion-big-nostalgia-cider-x-polly-pocket-pops-up-in-beverly-hills/

✍️: Ashley Lopez

-
#CiderxPollyPocket #ShopCider #PollyPocket #CiderGirls #CiderStyle #Alfreds
☀️Summer just kicked off with @dearsummerfesti ☀️Summer just kicked off with @dearsummerfestival. The HBCU kickback inspired festival that grew from a cultural campus phenomenon into becoming the latest and fastest-growing black-owned music festival. 🔥

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/inside-dear-summer-festival-the-black-owned-festival-gaining-national-momentum-built-by-hbcu-alumni/

✍️: Briana Boateng 
-
#MeekMill #Valiant #HBCU #DearSummerFestival
@tydollasign takes Tribeca. 🎥 The artist premie @tydollasign takes Tribeca. 🎥
The artist premiered his powerful new doc ‘Still Free TC’—a raw, emotional follow-up to his 2015 album—spotlighting family, justice, and legacy.
10 years later, the message still hits.

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/ty-dolla-ign-premieres-still-free-tc-documentary-at-tribeca-film-festival/

✍️: Kadeem Lundy

-
#StillFreeTC #TyDollaSign #TribecaFestival #MusicDocumentary #HipHopCulture #JusticeForTC #Tribeca2025
ENTER TO WIN a pair of tickets to July Fourth Fire ENTER TO WIN a pair of tickets to July Fourth Fireworks Spectacular with Earth, Wind & Fire at the Hollywood Bowl on July 2, 3, & 4th! Nine-time Grammy Award-winning icons and one of the best-selling artists of all - Earth, Wind & Fire brings their iconic and timeless catalog of music with hits like “September” and “Shining Star” for three thrilling nights of songs, fireworks and fun. If you don’t win the tickets…don’t worry we’ll have a 20% off code on select sections!
Here’s how to enter:
✅Follow @theknockturnal 
❤️Like this post
👯Tag the friend you want to bring with you

Giveaway ends Monday, June 23 @ 11:59PM EST/8:59PM PST ! 
#KnockturnalGiveaway #EarthWindFire #HollywoodBowl #Giveaway #Concert #LosAngeles
@squidgamenetflix Season 3 has entered the arena. @squidgamenetflix Season 3 has entered the arena. 🦑🩸

New players. Higher stakes. And a game that’s more brutal than ever.
The masks return—so does revenge. ⭕️🔺◼️

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/squid-game-season-3-premieres-in-new-york/

✍️: ElizaBeth Taylor 

-
#SquidGame #Season3 #NetflixOriginal #Netflix #TheGameContinues #LeeJungJae #Player456 #WiHaJoon #GongYoo #LeeByungHun
@f1movie crew makes a pitstop in NYC for their wor @f1movie crew makes a pitstop in NYC for their world premiere of their film “F1 The Movie” in Times Square and at Radio City Music Hall. 🏎️💨
-
#BradPitt #JavierBardem #DamsonIdris #AppleCEO #TimCook #JosephKosinski #JerryBruckheimer  #LewisHamilton #HansZimmer #F1 #F1Movie #F1Film
“Love doesn’t always disappear—it just chang “Love doesn’t always disappear—it just changes shape.” 🎶
In our exclusive interview, @yourfavoritecolor opens up about vulnerability, emotional distance, and the story behind their newest single, “Less In Love.”
This one hits different. 🥹

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/exclusive-interview-your-favorite-color-contemplates-connection-on-new-single-less-in-love/

✍️: Eleanor Jacobs

-
#ExclusiveInterview #YourFavoriteColor #LessInLove #IndieMusic
@saiebeauty Art of Glow pop-up bathed the city in @saiebeauty Art of Glow pop-up bathed the city in golden light with vintage lamps, curated cocktails, and radiant beauty moments—all in honor of the iconic Glowy Super Gel. A celebration of luminosity in every form. ✨

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/a-night-to-glow-inside-saies-art-of-glow-celebration/

✍️: Ashley Lopez

-
#SaieBeauty #ArtOfGlow #GlowySuperGel #LAEvents #CleanBeauty #GlowGoals #BeautyMeetsArt #LightUpLA
@mileycyrus steps into her pop opera era with Some @mileycyrus steps into her pop opera era with Something Beautiful — a 55-minute visual album that blurs the line between music, film, and fantasy. Premiered at Tribeca, now playing on the biggest screen: herself. 🎬✨ 

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/high-energy-higher-fashion-miley-cyruss-pop-opera-something-beautiful/

✍️: Jesse Kosierowski

-
#MileyCyrus #SomethingBeautiful #VisualAlbum #PopOpera #Tribeca2025 #EditorialMoment #MusicAndFilm #FashionInFilm
An intimate night of art, passion, and connection An intimate night of art, passion, and connection @centerforartandadvocacy celebrating the third release of @prisonerwineco featuring label designs by @jessekrime and a network of formerly incarcerated artists for the limited edition Wine Series. 🍷🎨
@omaribooker @jaredowensart @mrwashtheartist @r.craig.t1 

🔗: https://theknockturnal.com/the-prisoner-wine-company-unveils-third-limited-edition-corrections-series-at-the-center-for-art-advocacy-in-nyc/

✍️: Briana Boateng 

-
#PrisonerWineCo #ArtAdvocacy #Wine #Spirits #Art  #NikeCommPR
Follow on Instagram

About The Site

We are a collective of creative tastemakers made up of fashion, music and entertainment industry insiders. It’s all about access. You want it. We have it.

Terms Of Use

Privacy Policy

Meet The Team

CONTACT US

For general inquiries and more info on The Knockturnal, please contact our staff at:
info@theknockturnal.com
fashion@theknockturnal.com
advertising@theknockturnal.com
editorial@theknockturnal.com
beauty@theknockturnal.com

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube

© Copyright - The Knockturnal | Developed by CI Design + Media

The Knockturnal
  • Home
  • Entertainment
  • Music
  • Lifestyle
  • News
  • Videos
  • Covers
  • Merch