Legendary filmmaker Mike Leigh showcases the complexity of family and relationships with his new film, Hard Truths, which premiered at the 2024 New York Film Festival.
The film follows the story of two sisters Pansy, Marianne Jean-Baptiste, and Chantelle, Michele Austin, as they navigate the world of adulthood and sisterhood. Leigh depicted the vast differences that can come from two siblings raised in the same household.
Pansy who is tormented with anger, depression, and hypersensitivity serves as the complete opposite of her cheerful sister. In the film, you’ll notice that Pansy while married with a child still appears lonely. Chantelle on the other hand is a single mother of two young women, full of joy. She’s a hairstylist who enjoys connecting with her clients through engaging conversations. Whereas Pansy is unable to connect with strangers yet alone her own son, Moses played by Tuwaine Barrett. She finds herself in constant arguments with those she encounters along with feeling disconnected from her own family.
Mike captures Pansy’s depression through an intimate conversation with Chantelle. Where she questions why Pansy got married in which she states she didn’t want to be alone. In the same breath, Pansy expresses just how lonely she truly is despite having people around her. Throughout the film, Pansy is constantly snapping at her husband, son, and strangers. The most notable moment is when she sits at the dinner table with her family and is unable to eat her meal as she’s constantly complaining.
Chantelle who sees her sister struggle tries to brighten her days. She invites her to spend an evening at their mother’s grave and a family dinner. With much reluctance Pansy caves in but can only be overtaken with anger. As their day continues Pansy begins to break down as she realizes her coldness has left her feeling lonely. She notes that many people do not want to be around her because of her negativity. Chantelle who attempts to motivate her to be happier is partially successful.
As the film comes to an end Pansy attempts to find a sense of happiness and relief but is unsuccessful. Her husband Curtley, David Webber, becomes injured on the job. Pansy who is made aware of the situation appears to be disassociated. As her husband sits downstairs in pain she remains frozen in their bedroom. Reminding herself that no matter what happens around her she is tormented by her depression and hypersensitivity.
Overall, the film explores the complexities of adulthood and sibling relationships shaped by parental interactions. Focusing specifically on the complications that occur between older and younger siblings as they develop into adulthood.
